Error culture, or the difference between an error and a misjudgement

Ralf Metz & Andreas MesserliRalf Metz & Andreas Messerli·25 February 2019·6 min read
A signpost at a fork in the road: a yellow arrow reads “Error”, a green arrow reads “Misjudgement → Learning”.
Updated August 2026: What was a question of words in 2019 has become a real test through AI.

In recent years, the term “error culture” has been heard more and more often. People enthusiastically demand that one must also be allowed to fail, and frenetically celebrate their setbacks. At Fuck-Up Nights, entrepreneurs report on their defeats.

And yes, it is important that failing is not equated with lack of success. That it is socially accepted when something does not go as expected. If you look at the careers of most highly successful entrepreneurs, you will find that dozens, hundreds, sometimes thousands of failures preceded their success.

I have not failed. I have just found 10,000 ways that won’t work.

Thomas A. Edison, the inventor of the light bulb

Perhaps not all successful entrepreneurs, founders and researchers have had to make as many attempts as Thomas Edison. But in all likelihood, not a single one of them got to where they are now without failures and setbacks.

Elon Musk is a more recent example. He firmly believed in the success of reusable rockets. He took the risk and knew that one more failure and SpaceX would be finished economically. Success has proved him right. But what would have happened if it had taken three more attempts, for which he no longer had the financial means? Would we have said: Wow, great that you tried! Or: “We knew beforehand that this could never work. Loser!”

Because when people talk about an error culture, it is mostly exactly these qualities that are in demand at its core. The courage to try new things and to accept the risk of failing.

But why do so many companies find the topic so difficult?

At its core, it is a question of attitude, of trust, of the right conditions. After all, the word error alone seems to trigger resistance. As an alternative, one could use misjudgement instead of error.

Error or misjudgement, where is the difference?

Are Edison’s 10,000 ways of not doing it errors? We took a look at the dictionary. It says, roughly: error means something deviates from what is right. But it can also be a mistaken decision. And now it is time for a distinction.

Meaning of error

Through existing experience (either my own or my company’s), I could have known that the path would not achieve the desired result. That it can make sense to define a path for the standard execution of a repetitive task, such as travel expense claims, will probably be clear.

When I speak of an error, I therefore have a basis on which I can decide beforehand whether the result will be wrong or right. If, for example, I process travel expense claims with the wrong information, I make an error. No company wants too many of these events, since they are ultimately waste.

Note: Whether the process described actually makes sense is another matter.

Meaning of misjudgement

With questions, ideas and undertakings where, at the time of the decision, I do not yet know whether I will achieve the desired result, I work with assumptions and hypotheses. Only afterwards will it become clear whether I was right about them or not.

The big difference from an error: whether I am successful or not, I can learn something new from what I did. Because I tried something and, with that knowledge and experience, can choose a different, possibly more promising path in future.

If I repeat the same approach again, however, one can certainly speak of an error. Because I could have known better.

What this has to do with AI

We wrote this text in 2019. At that time, the difference between error and misjudgement was a matter of clarifying terms. Today it is about much more.

AI quickly delivers professional-looking output. That changes what a misjudgement costs and how hard it is to recognise.

A misjudgement presupposes that someone formulates an assumption, tests it and learns from the result. Anyone who hands thinking over to AI does not reformulate these steps but simply skips them. The result often looks clean but is rarely thought through. We call this workslop: work that looks like quality and on closer inspection is not, and thereby even causes additional costs.

And this is exactly where it shows whether a company has really understood the difference between error and misjudgement. Anyone who adopts AI answers without testing them against their own assumptions applies something they have not understood, and turns misjudgement into error. Because the knowledge advantage that would have prevented it from going wrong is missing.

Conversely, there are organisations in which AI triggers the exact opposite. There, someone puts forward a hypothesis, has AI provide counter-arguments, checks, discards, reformulates. The result is better because the human was involved in the thinking. In our article on AI as a thinking prosthesis or an exoskeleton we described this difference in more detail: the thinking prosthesis replaces thinking. The exoskeleton strengthens it.

Our conviction: AI amplifies what is already there, and thereby also reveals whether an error culture exists or not.

Just splitting hairs?

One could object that all this is, somewhere, just words. Which is true and not true at the same time. Among other things, the human brain works by pattern recognition. In this pattern recognition, error is quickly negatively loaded with “wrong”, and something unpleasant already resonates in it. No wonder, then, that leaders in particular struggle with the term.

So, once more in brief:

  • Error: At the time of my decision, I could already have known it was wrong.
  • Misjudgement: At the time of my decision, I could not yet have known better.

For us to learn from this in practice, it takes the willingness to take responsibility for what is your own, and it takes the structural possibility to actually do so. In our article on how responsibility arises we described this through the three dimensions permission, willingness and capability.

  • Permission means that the framework in the company permits misjudgement instead of sanctioning it.
  • Willingness means that someone decides inwardly to make an issue their own.
  • And capability means that judgement and the ability to learn are present, so that one actually takes something away from a misjudgement.

Without these three dimensions, error culture remains merely an empty phrase.

Two paths, where it gets concrete

If you want to work on your own attitude and the structural conditions in your area are in place, we support you with the digital programme Building self-responsibility in really living self-responsibility instead of merely describing it.

And if you are working with a team that needs real room for decision-making, we support you with Starting an empowered team in building this framework together. So that errors stay where they belong: they can happen, are worked through, one learns (ideally) from them and moves on.


We later developed this thought further in Why we should talk about a “learning culture” rather than an “error culture”.


Ralf Metz & Andreas Messerli

AuthorsRalf Metz & Andreas MesserliFounders of me&me · More about us
Next step

Ready for the next step?

In a free, no-obligation initial conversation, we look together at what fits your organisation. Concrete and to the point.

30 minutes. Free. No obligation.Further reading